May 4, 2025

How to Make the Most of A/B and Split Testing

By  
Eliott Wahba

No matter how well you know your audience, they will always surprise you.

Research can take you far—but only real-world testing reveals how customers truly behave. That’s why A/B testing remains one of the most valuable tools in modern marketing.

Whether it’s testing email subject lines or deciding which landing page layout works best, A/B testing allows brands to make decisions based on data, not guesses.

What is A/B Testing?

A/B testing (or split testing) compares two versions of an element—such as an email, ad, or landing page—to see which performs better.

Your audience is randomly divided. Group A sees one version. Group B sees the other.
The winner? Whichever option drives better results based on your goals (click-through rate, purchases, engagement, etc.).

Pro tip: Not everything needs to be tested. Focus your A/B tests where the outcome could meaningfully improve your business metrics.

A/B Testing vs. Split Testing—Any Difference?

In practice, A/B testing and split testing are the same.
"A/B" refers to the versions being tested.
"Split" refers to how the audience is divided.

Why A/B & Split Testing Matters

Here’s what proper testing delivers:

Higher ROI — optimize campaigns without increasing spend
User Experience Improvements — discover what customers prefer
Data-Driven Decisions — eliminate guesswork
Lower Bounce Rates — refine your content to keep audiences engaged
Trend Forecasting — test creative ideas before fully committing

What Marketing Elements Can You Test?

A/B testing works across almost everything:

  • Email subject lines
  • Call-to-action (CTA) button text and colors
  • Landing page layouts
  • Social media ad creatives
  • Video thumbnails
  • Pricing page layouts
  • Headlines and product descriptions

But—only test changes that are likely to impact user behavior meaningfully.

The A/B Testing Process

Step 1: Identify what to test
Focus on areas where a small change could significantly impact conversions or engagement.

Step 2: Create two strong variations
Don’t create a “throwaway” version. Both options should have winning potential.

Step 3: Set test parameters
Decide the sample size, duration, and success metrics before you begin.

Step 4: Launch the test
Use reliable testing tools and gather data.

Step 5: Analyze results
When the test concludes, compare results and apply your findings.

Interpreting Your Results

Don’t just declare a winner.
Ask why one variation performed better. What can this teach you about your audience’s preferences?

Also:

  • Avoid drawing conclusions too early
  • Look for statistically significant results
  • Watch for external factors (holidays, competitor campaigns, etc.)

The #1 Rule: Great Creative Fuels Great Testing

A/B testing demands twice the creative.
Without enough creative variation, you won’t gather actionable insights.

This is where brands often hit a wall—they want to test, but they don’t have the creative bandwidth to develop high-quality options for testing at scale.

How DolFinContent Helps Leading Brands Win at Testing

DolFinContent empowers brands by delivering rapid, high-quality creative variations ready for A/B testing across every platform.

Case Example: Riverstone Financial

Riverstone Financial wanted to optimize lead generation ads across Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.

Working with DolFinContent’s dedicated creative team, Riverstone developed over 50 ad variations in the first quarter alone. Tests focused on:

  • Visual layout
  • Messaging tone
  • Call-to-action phrasing
  • Audience segmentation

Result?
Click-through rates doubled within eight weeks, and cost-per-lead dropped by 41%.

This wouldn’t have been possible without a constant stream of fresh, brand-consistent creative.

A/B Testing Tools We Recommend

  • Google Optimize (for simple web and app testing)
  • VWO (full-featured enterprise platform)
  • Optimizely (robust for large-scale testing)
  • Mailchimp (built-in email A/B testing)
  • Unbounce (landing page testing made easy)

Common A/B Testing Mistakes

  • Testing too many things at once
    Only test one variable per experiment.
  • Choosing the wrong metrics
    Match your success metrics to your goals.
  • Trusting gut over data
    If the numbers say you’re wrong—listen to them.
  • Ignoring external factors
    Major events, seasonality, or audience changes can skew results.
  • Stopping after one test
    Continuous testing is the key to optimization.

Real-World A/B Testing Examples

DolFinContent Client: PeakPath Outdoors
PeakPath tested two variations of a product landing page for a spring promotion.
Version A had a lifestyle photo hero image.
Version B used a bold product-only hero image.

Result? Version B outperformed by 37% in conversion rate—despite internal opinions favoring Version A.

BrightLeaf Learning
BrightLeaf tested video vs. static image ads on TikTok.
Video ads produced 3x higher engagement and reduced cost-per-click by 52%.

Final Best Practices

  • Pre-plan tests carefully
  • Keep designs mobile-friendly
  • Be patient—seek statistically valid results
  • Document learnings for future campaigns

Want Better Test Results? Start With Better Creative

A/B testing without powerful creative is like racing with flat tires.

DolFinContent’s Creative-as-a-Service model provides unlimited design variations so you can test what really matters—without bottlenecks, delays or extra headcount.

Let’s Chat